Presupposition Accommodation of Discourse-Initial Too
نویسنده
چکیده
Sentences with a Japanese focus marker mo “also/too” can be uttered out of the blue without sounding erratic. Instead of contrastive narrow focus, mo-sentences have presentational neutral focus. I will analyze discourse-initial mo as a speakeroriented emphatic marker, similar to indeed or unfortunately. By association with a whole proposition, mo triggers unspecified presuppositions that provide evidence to convince the speaker and hearer that p is true. Even though the presuppositions accommodated by the hearer might differ from those of the speaker, they are similar propositions to p. 1 Discourse Initial Mo “also” Mo “also/even,” a focus marker or quantifier-like element (Kuroda 1969), typically places contrastive focus on a noun phrase. Similar to the English too (Karttunen and Peters 1979), a mo-p assertion is felicitous only when it follows another sentence, such as “someone other than Ken came,” or at least when the presuppositions are satisfied by the extralinguistic context. This paper, however, concerns mo-p that is uttered discourseinitially. (1) Yo-mo hukete-ta. night-also grow late-past “It has become late, indeed.” Such a mo-sentence can be uttered out of the blue without sounding remotely peculiar. Unlike the regular mo, the discourse-initial mo does not contrast its syntactic constituent yo “night” with any antecedent. The focus in (1) is neutral and presentational. Instead of a narrow focus on the noun phrase, there is wide focus on the whole sentence. Mo does not trigger the presupposition that “someone/something other than x is so.” For example, (1) does not presuppose that “the morning grew late and the night grew late, too,” and it is perfectly felicitous out of the blue without antecedents. (2) Haru-mo takenawa-ni nari-mashi-ta. (Numata 2000) spring-also peak-dat become-hon-past “Spring has reached its peak.”
منابع مشابه
Presupposition Accommodation by Discourse-Initial Evidential Marker Mo
A Japanese focus marker mo ‘also/too’ can be uttered out of the blue without oddness. Instead of contrastive narrow focus, mo-sentences have presentational neutral focus. I will analyze this mo as universal evidential marker based on visual evidences which is also a speaker-oriented emphatic marker similar to indeed and unfortunately. By association with a whole proposition, mo triggers unspeci...
متن کاملPresupposition And VP-Ellipsis
We discuss a treatment of VP-ellipsis resolution in DRT in general, and particularly cases where the source clause of the elliptical VP contains presupposition triggers. We propose to restrain VP-elfipsis resolution by presupposition neutralization. We view presupposition as a kind of anaphora, with the ability to accommodate an antecedent if not provided by discourse. 1 I n t r o d u c t i o n...
متن کاملPresupposition Accommodation as Exception Handling
Van der Sandt’s algorithm for handling presupposition is based on a “presupposition as anaphora” paradigm and is expressed in the realm of Kamp’s DRT. In recent years, we have proposed a typetheoretic rebuilding of DRT that allows Montague’s semantics to be combined with discourse dynamics. Here we explore van der Sandt’s theory along the line of this formal framework. It then results that pres...
متن کاملThe Meaning of the Additive Too: Presupposition and Discourse Similarity
This paper studies the general meaning of the additive particle too. It is argued that besides its well-known presuppositional content, too also conveys an information regarding the similarity of its host and the antecedent of its presupposition in the discourse. We couch our proposal in an argumentative framework. This proposal is then articulated with recent accounts of the obligatoriness of ...
متن کاملImplementing the Binding and Accommodation Theory for Anaphora Resolution and Presupposition Projection
Computational aspects of Van der Sandt’s binding and accommodation theory (BAT) for presupposition projection and anaphora resolution are presented and discussed in this article. BAT is reformulated to meet requirements for computational implementation, which include operations on discourse representation structures (renaming and merging), the representation of presuppositions (allowing for sel...
متن کامل